Avra Estiatorio
Greece and France Walk Into a Wine List
Midtown East ยท New York ยท Greek ยท Visit Website โ
Reviewed April 8, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
The wine list at Avra lands like a confident handshake โ thick, organized, and unapologetically Greek-forward before pivoting into serious French and Italian territory. This is not a restaurant that slapped together a wine list as an afterthought between marble deliveries. Between the white tablecloths and the smell of fresh fish, you're holding something that earned its Best of Award of Excellence from Wine Spectator for a reason.
Selection Deep Dive
Four hundred to six hundred selections is a big room, and Avra fills it well. The Greek section alone could carry this list โ Domaine Sigalas Assyrtiko, Hatzidakis Winery Santorini, Gaia Thalassitis, Gerovassiliou Malagousia, and both Kir-Yianni and Alpha Estate Xinomavro give you a proper education in Greek wine without feeling like a lecture. Then the list pivots hard into Burgundy with names like Domaine Leflaive Puligny-Montrachet and Louis Jadot, Champagne courtesy of Krug and Bollinger, Tuscany with Antinori, and California via Ridge Vineyards. The gaps are minor โ you're not getting deep South American or German coverage โ but for this cuisine and this room, the list is doing exactly what it should.
By the Glass
Twenty to thirty-five pours by the glass is an ambitious program, and Avra commits. Expect Greek whites to anchor the selection โ Assyrtiko and Malagousia show up and they should โ alongside enough French and Italian representation to keep the table happy regardless of what hits the fish course. Sommelier Sasha Brumfield runs the floor, and that matters: pours rotate thoughtfully rather than sitting stale.
Gaia Estate Thalassitis Assyrtiko 2021 โ $85
Eighty-five dollars for one of Santorini's benchmark Assyrtikos in a room like this is as close to fair as you're going to find. It's a wine that punches at the $40-50 retail range, so the markup stings slightly, but in the context of Manhattan fine dining next to $1,200 Margaux and $3,500 Screaming Eagle, this is your move โ especially alongside the grilled whole dorade.
Domaine Gerovassiliou Malagousia
Most tables at Avra lock in on Assyrtiko and never look left. Malagousia is the grape they're sleeping on โ floral, textured, and totally unlike anything French or Californian on this list. Gerovassiliou basically rescued the variety from extinction, and drinking it here feels appropriately theatrical for the room.
Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2019
Thirty-five hundred dollars for a bottle of California Cab in a Greek seafood restaurant is a choice, and not one we'd endorse. We get it โ trophy bottles draw trophy diners โ but this has nothing to do with the food, the region, or the spirit of this list. Save it for a steakhouse where it at least makes thematic sense.
Domaine Sigalas Assyrtiko + Whole Dorade
Santorini Assyrtiko and a whole grilled sea bream is one of the most honest pairings in the book โ both are creatures of the Aegean, both have saline edges and clean minerality that amplify each other. Sigalas is one of the island's most serious producers, and this combination is the reason Avra exists.
Monday โ Half-price wine night every Monday โ one of the better deals in Midtown if you're planning ahead.
๐ฅ The Bottom Line
Avra's wine list is the real deal โ a Greek-anchored, France-supported, professionally managed program that earns every star on its Wine Spectator plaque. The markup on prestige bottles is steep, but get into the Greek selections and you're drinking seriously and smartly; come on Monday for half-price bottles and you might never leave.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.