Come for the Guinness, not the Grenache
Tipperary Hill · Syracuse · Irish Pub · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed April 23, 2026
Wingman Metrics
Coleman's is a Syracuse institution and an honest-to-god neighborhood Irish pub — the kind of place where the Shamrock flag flies out front and everyone at the bar knows each other's first name. The wine list reads exactly like what it is: an afterthought bolted onto a beer-and-whiskey operation. Nobody came here for wine, and the list knows it.
Fifteen labels, almost all of them familiar faces from the bottom shelf of your local grocery store. CK Mondavi shows up three times — Chardonnay, Cabernet, Merlot — which tells you everything you need to know about the curatorial ambition here. There are a couple of bright spots: Whispering Angel Rosé brings a touch of Provence credibility, and Dr. Frank Riesling is a genuine nod to the Finger Lakes, which is practically in Coleman's backyard. The Altos Del Plata Malbec rounds out an otherwise California-heavy list with a bit of South American muscle. Everything else is filler.
Fourteen of the fifteen labels are available by the glass, which is generous in volume if not in quality. You're essentially getting the entire list poured one glass at a time, which is convenient when you just want something wet and red while you work through a shepherd's pie. Don't expect any rotation — this list has the energy of something that hasn't changed since the last World Cup.
Dr. Frank Riesling — null
No price data available from the source, but Dr. Frank's Finger Lakes Riesling is the most legitimate bottle on this list — crisp, food-friendly, and actually grown nearby. If it's priced inline with the rest of the list, it's the clear move.
Altos Del Plata Malbec
In a list dominated by California house pours, this Argentine Malbec is the quiet overachiever. Dark fruit, some grip, and it holds up to Coleman's hearty pub food in a way that a CK Mondavi Merlot simply cannot.
Beringer White Zinfandel
There is no scenario at an Irish pub — or really anywhere — where you need to be drinking White Zinfandel in 2024. This one exists purely to round out the list. Leave it alone.
Dr. Frank Riesling + Fish and Chips
A dry Finger Lakes Riesling has the acidity to cut through the fried batter and the brightness to complement the fish. It's the kind of pairing that makes you feel like someone at this pub actually thought it through — even if they didn't.
❌ The Bottom Line
Coleman's is a great Irish pub that happens to have wine on the menu — emphasis on 'happens to.' Order a Guinness, grab a Jameson, and if someone at the table insists on wine, point them toward the Dr. Frank and move on.
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.