Gordito's
Birria and Burgundy? No, but close enough.
Capitol Hill · Seattle · Mexican
Reviewed April 24, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
You come in for tacos and tequila — that's the pitch, that's the promise — and then you notice an 80-label wine list sitting quietly on the back of the menu like it has something to prove. For a lively, no-reservations taco spot in Capitol Hill, this is not what we expected. That's a good thing.
Selection Deep Dive
The list leans California and South America with a nod to Spain, which makes sense given the cuisine but also keeps things accessible without being lazy. Tablas Creek showing up on a birria menu is the kind of small surprise that earns goodwill fast — that's a Paso Robles producer with serious chops, not a bulk-wine filler. Achaval Ferrer Malbec from Mendoza is another smart pick: it's a name that wine drinkers recognize and respect. We'd love to see more depth in Spanish and Mexican wine specifically, since the cuisine calls for it, but what's here is genuinely curated.
By the Glass
Ten pours by the glass in the $10–$16 range is a respectable showing for a casual Mexican spot. The pricing keeps things approachable without bottoming out into house-wine purgatory. We don't have the full glass list in front of us, but at these price points, there's room to explore without committing to a bottle.
Achaval Ferrer Malbec 2020 — $62
Retail sits around $45, so the markup is under 40% — practically a gift by restaurant standards. This is a full-throttle Mendoza Malbec from one of Argentina's most consistent producers. Order it with the carnitas and don't overthink it.
Tablas Creek Esprit Blanc 2021
Most people at a taco spot are reaching for a margarita or a cold beer, which means this Rhône-style white from Paso Robles gets left on the shelf. That's a mistake. It's textured, aromatic, and built to handle spice and richness — exactly what's on this menu.
Tablas Creek Esprit Blanc 2021
At $55 on the list versus $38 retail, the markup is on the higher end of fair — nearly 45%. If you're watching your spend, this is the one to pass on in favor of the Malbec, which is marked up more gently. The wine itself is great; the math is just slightly less friendly.
Achaval Ferrer Malbec 2020 + Birria Tacos
Braised, chile-stewed beef needs a wine with enough fruit and body to stand up to it without fighting it. Achaval Ferrer's Malbec has the dark fruit and structure to match birria's richness while the consommé dipping cup does the rest of the work.
🎲 The Bottom Line
Gordito's is a taco spot that quietly takes wine more seriously than it has any obligation to, and we respect the hustle. The markups are fair, the picks are smart, and it's the kind of list that rewards the one person at the table who actually looks at it.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.