Sign In

or

No password needed — we'll email you a sign-in link.

✔️The Reliable

Puritan & Company

Familiar Bottles, No Surprises, No Complaints

Inman Square · Manchester · New American · Visit Website ↗

casual-vibesdate-nightnew-world-explorerby-the-glass-hero

Reviewed April 13, 2026

Wingman Metrics

List VarietyCrowd Pleasers
MarkupFair
GlasswareBasic Stemmed
StaffWilling but Green
Specials & DealsSet & Forget
Storage & TempAcceptable

First Impression

The wine list at Puritan & Company reads like a greatest hits album you already own — Kim Crawford, Meiomi, Kendall-Jackson, Coppola. There's nothing here that will make a wine nerd's pulse quicken, but there's also nothing that will embarrass you in front of a date. It's a list built for the room, and the room seems just fine with that.

Selection Deep Dive

Twenty-five to forty bottles covering California, Italy, New Zealand, Oregon, Argentina, and France — on paper that sounds like range, but in practice it's a parade of grocery-store staples. The California contingent dominates with J. Lohr, Murphy Goode, and Noble Vines doing the heavy lifting, while Argentina shows up with Altos del Plata Malbec as the lone representative of anything with a little more character. There's a token nod to Oregon via Rainstorm Pinot Gris, which is actually the most interesting regional detour on the list. Gaps are real: no Burgundy, no Rhône, no Riesling, nothing aged, nothing that suggests anyone is particularly passionate about what goes in the glass.

By the Glass

Ten to fifteen pours by the glass is a respectable count, and the spread mirrors the bottle list — workmanlike and approachable. You're picking from the same roster of commercial labels, so don't expect a rotating slate of interesting finds. What you do get is options at multiple price points, which makes it easy to drink reasonably well without committing to a full bottle.

💰Best Value

Rainstorm Pinot Gris, Oregon — $17

Oregon Pinot Gris at the low end of the price range is the smartest pour on this list — more texture and personality than the MezzaCorona sitting next to it, and it holds its own against the New American small plates.

💎Hidden Gem

Altos del Plata Malbec, Argentina

Everyone's ordering the Meiomi or the Coppola Cab, but the Altos del Plata Malbec is the sleeper — Argentine Malbec at this price point typically punches well above its weight, and it's a better match for the roasted chicken and pasta than the California reds crowding it out.

Skip This

Moet & Chandon Brut NV

At $65 on the list versus ~$45 retail, it's not highway robbery, but Moët is a party-bus Champagne dressed in a tuxedo price tag. There's nothing wrong with it, but you're paying a premium for the name recognition when that $17 Lamberti Prosecco does the celebratory job just fine for a fraction of the spend.

🍽️Perfect Pairing

J. Lohr Riverstone Chardonnay, CA + Roasted Chicken

J. Lohr Riverstone is a lightly oaked, fruit-forward California Chardonnay that doesn't bulldoze the plate — it's soft enough to let the roasted chicken's herby, savory notes come through without getting steamrolled by butter bombs.

✔️ The Bottom Line

Puritan & Company is a genuinely good neighborhood restaurant whose wine list exists to not get in the way — and on that mission it succeeds. Send a friend here for the food and the vibe; just don't send them expecting anything to talk about in the car on the way home.

Comments

Cmd+Enter to post
Loading comments...

Sign In

or

No password needed — we'll email you a sign-in link.

Get the Weekly Wingman

One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.