Tapateria Tapatria
Spain's sleeper hits, hiding in Colorado
Old Colorado City · Colorado Springs · Spanish Tapas · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed April 9, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
The wine list at Tapateria reads like someone actually went to Spain, wandered off the tourist trail, and took notes. Forty bottles, almost entirely Iberian, leaning hard into indigenous grapes most Colorado diners couldn't name — and that's exactly the point. This isn't a list built around what sells; it's built around what's interesting.
Selection Deep Dive
Galicia shows up strong with the A Telleira Godello and Avancia Cuvée de O Mencía, both solid representatives of Spain's northwest and a clear signal that whoever curated this list knows their regions. The Villota Selvanevada Blanco and Alto Horizonte Altitud round out a range that spans Atlantic freshness to high-altitude Castilian weight. The Pedro Ximénez de Añada is a nod to dessert-wine territory that most tapas spots wouldn't bother with. Gaps exist — you won't find much Priorat or Ribera depth — but for 40 bottles, the intentionality here punches well above its weight.
By the Glass
By-the-glass specifics aren't confirmed from available data, so we can't count pours or guarantee rotation. What we can say is that with pricing this accessible on the bottle side, the by-the-glass program — whatever it looks like — should be an easy yes.
Dehesa La Granja Tierra de Castilla y León — $12
Retails for $20 and they're charging $12. That's not a markup, that's a gift. A big, structured Castilian red that should cost you twice this at any other restaurant in the Springs.
Avancia Cuvée de O Mencía
Mencía is one of Spain's most compelling red grapes — think cool-climate fruit, earthy tension, and a savory finish — and most people walk right past it. Don't. This is the bottle to order when everyone else is reaching for Rioja.
El Coto Crianza Rioja
At $11 it's technically not a rip-off, but El Coto is the grocery store Rioja that shows up everywhere. With the Mencía and the Castilla y León on the same list at similar prices, there's no reason to default to the safe pick.
A Telleira Godello + Patatas Bravas
Godello has enough body to handle the smoky paprika heat of bravas sauce without the bitterness a big red would bring. It cuts the richness of the potato and keeps the whole thing lively. An underrated call that most tables will walk right past.
🎲 The Bottom Line
Tapateria is doing something genuinely rare in Colorado Springs: building a wine list that matches the food's ambition rather than catering to the lowest common denominator. The pricing alone makes it worth the trip, but the list's dedication to real Spanish regionality is what earns the repeat visits.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.