Sign In

or

No password needed — we'll email you a sign-in link.

🎲The Wild Card

The Preacher's Son

Church Pews, 250 Labels, Zero Apologies

Bentonville · Fayetteville · New American · Visit Website ↗

deep-cellardate-nightsplurge-worthyold-world-focus

Reviewed April 13, 2026

Wingman Metrics

List VarietyDeep & Eclectic
MarkupSteep
GlasswareVarietal Specific
StaffKnowledgeable & Friendly
Specials & DealsSet & Forget
Storage & TempProper

First Impression

You walk into a converted church in northwest Arkansas and get handed a 250-label wine list — that's the whole premise, and it works. The setting alone earns a double-take, but the list backs it up with Sassicaia, Egon Müller, and Pahlmeyer sitting alongside approachable crowd pleasers. This is not the wine program you expect to find between Walmart HQ and a Cracker Barrel.

Selection Deep Dive

The list leans hard into Tuscany, Napa, and the Mosel, and it does all three with genuine conviction — Sassicaia 2019 and Pahlmeyer's Proprietary Red are legitimate trophy bottles, not just name-drops. The Egon Müller Scharzhofberger Riesling Kabinett showing up in Bentonville is quietly remarkable; that wine barely makes it to major city restaurant lists. Gaps exist — if you want natural wine, Burgundy depth, or South American options, you'll be hunting — but the anchor regions are handled with real seriousness. A sommelier is on staff, and you can tell: this list has a point of view.

By the Glass

Twenty-two by-the-glass options is a generous pour program, ranging from $13 to $25 a glass, with enough spread across white, red, and presumably sparkling to keep a table happy without committing to a bottle. The program feels curated rather than just default Chardonnay-and-Cab territory, though we'd love to see more rotation to keep regulars on their toes. At the top end of the glass pour range, you're getting into genuinely interesting territory.

đź’°Best Value

Rombauer Chardonnay 2022 — $72

A 60% markup is the most restrained pricing on the list — everything else runs 85% to 133% over retail. Rombauer is a known quantity that overdelivers for the crowd that loves big, buttery Chardonnay, and at $72 versus the $85-$110 alternatives, it's where the math makes the most sense.

đź’ŽHidden Gem

Egon MĂĽller Scharzhofberger Riesling Kabinett

Most tables here are ordering Napa Cab and Chardonnay, which means this bottle sits quietly on the list waiting for someone to notice it. Egon Müller is one of the most revered Riesling producers on the planet, and the Kabinett is the entry point into that world — electric acidity, orchard fruit, and a weight that makes it one of the most food-friendly wines you'll drink all year.

â›”Skip This

Kim Crawford Sauvignon Blanc 2023

A 127% markup on a $15 retail bottle puts this at $34 — the worst value math on the list. Kim Crawford is a perfectly fine grocery store Sauvignon Blanc, but paying $34 for it in a restaurant with an Egon Müller on the same list is a miss. Order literally anything else.

🍽️Perfect Pairing

Flowers Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 2021 + Smoked Pork Belly

Flowers Sonoma Coast Pinot brings enough red fruit and earthy lift to cut through the fat in the pork belly without fighting the smoke. It's a classically structured California Pinot that actually earns its place at the table here rather than just riding the label.

🎲 The Bottom Line

The Preacher's Son is the most surprising wine program in Arkansas — full stop — and the converted church setting makes it one of the more memorable places to drink in the South. The markups will sting on the mid-tier bottles, but a sommelier-driven list of 250 labels with Egon Müller and Sassicaia in Bentonville is worth the trip.

Comments

Cmd+Enter to post
Loading comments...

Sign In

or

No password needed — we'll email you a sign-in link.

Get the Weekly Wingman

One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.