The Toasted Frog
Fargo's Friendly Pour That Won't Break You
Downtown Fargo · Fargo · American · Visit Website ↗
Reviewed April 16, 2026
Wingman Metrics
First Impression
The Toasted Frog isn't trying to be a wine bar — and honestly, that's fine. The list reads like a greatest hits of recognizable labels at prices that won't make you do a double-take, which is more than most Fargo spots can claim. It's the kind of wine program that says 'we thought about this' without saying 'we obsessed over this.'
Selection Deep Dive
The list leans hard into California and Pacific Northwest familiars, with a few international ringers — Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc, an Argentinian Malbec, a Bordeaux Blanc — thrown in to keep things honest. You're not going to find a grower Champagne or a skin-contact Gruner here, but Erath Pinot Noir from Willamette and Ferrari Carano Pinot Grigio are solid workhorses that belong on any casual list. The gaps are real: no Rhône, no Burgundy, no depth for the wine-curious diner who wants to wander. Still, what they've chosen, they've priced fairly.
By the Glass
Glass pours appear to track closely with the bottle list, covering the main bases — a white or two, a couple of reds, likely a rosé when the season calls for it. Specific rotation details are thin, but the price points on pours suggest you're not getting gouged on the glass. Nothing here is going to make you text your friends in excitement, but you also won't feel robbed.
Erath Pinot Noir Willamette — $10
Retail on Erath hovers around $20, so a $10 glass pour is genuinely solid value for a real Willamette Pinot Noir — not a California imitation. This is the move for anyone who wants something with actual personality on this list.
La Comtesse Bordeaux Blanc
Nobody in Fargo is ordering a Bordeaux Blanc at a place known for Buffalo Wings, which is exactly why you should. It's crisp, food-friendly, and a small step outside the Sauvignon Blanc comfort zone most tables never leave.
Seaglass Riesling California
At $9 a glass it seems fine, but Seaglass is a mass-market bottle that retails for $12 — you're paying restaurant prices for something you'd barely reach for at the grocery store. If you want a white, the Ferrari Carano or Bordeaux Blanc are better uses of your dollar.
Montes Malbec Argentina + Gorgonzola Butter Filet Mignon
A Malbec with a butter-basted filet and pungent blue cheese is one of those combinations that just works — the fruit and structure in the Montes cuts through the fat and doesn't fight the cheese. At $10 a glass next to a premium steak, it's the easiest call on the table.
✔️ The Bottom Line
The Toasted Frog isn't a wine destination, but it's a reliable pour in a city where that's not guaranteed — fair prices, recognizable labels, and nothing embarrassing on the list. Send a friend here for dinner knowing they won't be stuck drinking plonk at markup.
Comments
Get the Weekly Wingman
One wine list review, one adventure pick, one quick tip, and a personal note. Every week. Under 500 words.